Preorders are open. $39.99 a pair, two sizes, five colorways. Reserve a pair.
Home›Field notes›Getting outside›Baby Foot Development: Why Soft, Flexible Soles Matter
Field note Nº 30 · Getting outside · · 6 min

Baby Foot Development: Why Soft, Flexible Soles Matter

What pediatric guidance says about baby foot development: barefoot first, soft flexible soles for new walkers, arch development, and when stiff soles matter.

Pediatric guidance on baby footwear is consistent: barefoot is best indoors, shoes are for protection outdoors, and when a baby or new walker does wear shoes they should be lightweight, flexible and roomy, with a sole that bends easily and a non-skid surface. Stiff, supportive soles are not recommended for typical developing feet at this age. That is the short answer, and it comes from the American Academy of Pediatrics and from pediatric orthopedic and podiatric societies rather than from shoe companies. This post explains why, what is actually happening in a baby's foot, and when a stiffer sole does have a place.

A disclosure before we start: we make waterproof crawling booties for babies, so we have an interest in this topic. We have tried to stick to what the guidance says and to be clear about what it does not. Newt Boots keep feet dry; we do not claim they improve development.

What a baby's foot is made of

A newborn's foot is mostly cartilage and fat. The bones you would see on an adult x-ray are present as soft cartilage models that gradually harden into bone through childhood, a process that is not complete until the late teens. The foot is flat, wide and soft, with a thick pad of fat under the arch area that makes nearly every baby look flat-footed. That appearance is normal. The visible arch typically develops over the preschool years as the fat pad thins and the muscles, ligaments and bones mature.

Two practical consequences follow. First, a baby's foot is easily shaped by what is around it, which is the argument for roomy, soft footwear and against anything tight or rigid. Second, there is no arch to "support" in a healthy baby or toddler, so arch support in footwear for this age is not addressing a real need.

What the pediatric guidance says

The American Academy of Pediatrics, through its parent site HealthyChildren.org, advises that babies do not need shoes until they are walking outside, that going barefoot indoors helps a baby learn to walk by letting them feel the floor, and that when shoes are needed they should be flexible, lightweight, roomy and have a non-skid sole. The AAP also notes that most children's feet develop normally and that flat feet in toddlers usually resolve without treatment.

Pediatric orthopedic groups give similar advice. The general position is that for a typically developing child, shoes exist to protect the foot from the environment, not to shape it, and that the best shoe is the one that interferes least with the foot's own movement.

Research on footwear and foot development supports the direction of this advice without proving strong effects. A frequently cited 1992 study in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (British volume) by Rao and Joseph surveyed over two thousand children in India and found flat feet were more common among children who wore closed-toe shoes than among those who went barefoot or wore sandals. More recent work, including a 2017 study by Hollander and colleagues in Scientific Reports comparing habitually barefoot and shod children, found differences in foot shape and motor skills associated with barefoot habits. These are observational studies, and they suggest an association, not a guarantee. We would summarize the evidence as: habitual barefoot and minimal footwear are associated with foot development patterns that researchers generally consider healthy, and there is no evidence that stiff, supportive shoes help a typically developing child.

If you want a plain-language source to read yourself, HealthyChildren.org is the one we point parents to: healthychildren.org.

For amphibious babies.

Waterproof crawling booties, $39.99. Two sizes, five colorways. Preorders open.

Preorder

Why flexibility matters for new walkers

Learning to walk is a balance problem, and the foot is a sensor as much as a platform. A soft sole lets the foot do several things that matter at this stage:

  • Feel the ground. Thousands of nerve endings in the sole report surface, slope and texture. A thick stiff sole mutes that information.
  • Grip with the toes. New walkers spread and curl their toes constantly. A rigid sole and a narrow toe box prevent it.
  • Bend at the ball of the foot. Walking requires the foot to flex where the toes meet the foot. A sole that does not bend there forces the child to lift the whole foot like a block.
  • Build strength. The small muscles in the foot develop by working. A supportive shoe does the work for them.

None of this means a soft sole will make your child walk sooner or better. It means a stiff one is more likely to get in the way. The difference matters for how we talk about footwear: the goal is to not interfere, not to improve.

Why this matters for boots specifically

Rain boots are the exception that tends to break the rule. Parents who would never put a hard shoe on a one-year-old put a hard rubber boot on one every wet day from October to March, because that is what rain boots are. Molded rubber boots are stiff, heavy for their size, cold, and shaped like a small adult boot. On a pre-walker or new walker they do three unhelpful things: they do not bend where the foot bends, they lever off the heel with every step, and they fall off.

The alternative is a boot that behaves like a soft shoe and happens to be waterproof: a flexible sole that bends in your hand, a wide toe box, light weight, and a cuff that holds it on without squeezing the foot. That is the type to look for once a child is walking. Our own booties sit a step earlier: Newt Boots are waterproof crawling booties for the crawling stage, roughly 6 to 18 months, worn over a rain suit, and they look different from a rubber boot because they are not a boot for walking at all. Details are on our how they work page.

When you compare materials, the rubber vs neoprene vs fabric post goes through what each does to flexibility and weight.

When a stiffer sole does make sense

Flexibility is the default, not a rule for every situation. A firmer sole is appropriate when:

  • Terrain demands it. Sharp rock, thorns and hot surfaces call for more protection underfoot. A preschooler on a talus field needs a sturdier shoe than a toddler in a muddy park.
  • A clinician recommends it. Some children have conditions, such as significant toe-walking, certain forms of flat foot that cause pain, or neuromuscular differences, where a pediatrician, pediatric orthopedist or podiatrist may recommend specific footwear or orthotics. Follow that advice over any general guidance, including ours.
  • The child is older and running on hard surfaces. By the preschool and early school years, the foot has more bone and the activity changes. Shoes still should bend at the ball, but a bit more sole makes sense.

What is not a reason for stiffness: a baby who looks flat-footed, a toddler who is not walking yet, or a sales pitch about ankle support. Ankle support in baby shoes does not have evidence behind it for typical children.

A simple test for any baby shoe or boot

Hold the shoe with one hand at the heel and one at the toe and bend it. It should fold easily at the ball of the foot, where the toes meet the foot, not in the middle of the arch and not with effort. Then twist it gently; it should give. Then weigh it in your hand against a sock. If it feels heavy for a foot that small, it probably is.

Check the inside too: a wide, rounded toe area, no seams that press on the top of the foot, and about a thumb's width of room beyond the longest toe. Our sizing guide covers how to measure.

What we are and are not saying

We are saying: pediatric guidance favors soft, flexible, roomy footwear for babies and new walkers. Our booties are for crawlers, before any of that comes into play; they are waterproof and worn over a rain suit, and that is the extent of what we claim for them.

We are not saying: that our booties or any soft shoe improve development, prevent flat feet, or make children walk better. The evidence is not there for those claims, and we would rather you trust us on the things we can show, like dry feet.

If your child's feet or walking worry you, ask your pediatrician. For most kids, the answer will be that everything is normal and to let them run around barefoot as much as the weather allows. When the weather does not allow, that is when we come in. See when can babies wear shoes outside for the timing.

FAQ

When do babies need shoes?
Pediatric guidance says babies do not need shoes until they are walking outside. Indoors, barefoot is preferred. Before that, footwear is for warmth and protection, not for walking.
Are soft-soled shoes better for babies?
Pediatric guidance favors lightweight, flexible, roomy shoes with a non-skid sole for babies and new walkers. Soft soles let the foot feel the ground and bend naturally; the evidence does not show that they actively improve development.
Is it normal for a toddler to have flat feet?
Yes. Nearly all babies and toddlers look flat-footed because of a fat pad under the arch. The arch usually appears over the preschool years. Ask a pediatrician if the feet hurt or walking looks unusual.
Do babies need arch support in shoes?
Not for typically developing feet. There is no arch to support yet, and pediatric guidance does not recommend supportive shoes for babies and toddlers unless a clinician advises them.
Do soft-soled rain boots keep feet dry?
They can, if the shell is waterproof and the seams are sealed. Newt Boots are waterproof crawling booties; see our guide to what waterproof really means for how to check any boot.
The Newt Boots field desk
Parents and outdoor-business owners in Hood River, Oregon. We make waterproof crawling booties and spend a lot of time outside in the rain. About us.

Keep reading.

All field notes