Preorders are open. $39.99 a pair, two sizes, five colorways. Reserve a pair.
Home›Field notes›Buying guides›How to Keep Boots on a Toddler (7 Things That Work)
Field note Nº 4 · Buying guides · · 7 min

How to Keep Boots on a Toddler (7 Things That Work)

Seven ways to keep rain boots on a toddler who kicks them off: fix the cuff, the fit, and the socks, and know when the boot itself is the real problem.

Boots stay on a toddler when something above the ankle holds them there. Under about age two, a child's heel is too soft and shallow to grip a boot, so an open-top boot relies on luck. The fastest fixes are a cuff that cinches, a boot that fits the leg and not just the foot, and socks that give the boot something to hold. If you have tried all that and the boot still ends up in the stroller basket, the boot is the wrong type for the age.

Here are the seven things that actually work, in the order we would try them.

Why toddler boots fall off in the first place

It helps to know what you are fighting.

  • No heel. Babies and new walkers have a rounded, padded heel with very little definition. A boot's heel pocket has nothing to catch.
  • Kicking. A child in a carrier or stroller kicks constantly. Each kick is a small tug on the boot.
  • High steps. New walkers lift their feet much higher than they need to. Every high step lets the boot slide.
  • Weight. A heavy boot on a short leg swings like a pendulum and works itself loose.
  • Wrong size. Too big is obvious. Too small is less obvious: a boot that is tight across the top of the foot pops off the heel.
  • Slippery socks. A smooth nylon sock inside a smooth boot lining is a bearing.

Every fix below attacks one or more of these.

1. Close the cuff

The single most effective fix. A boot that closes above the ankle stays on no matter what the heel does.

If your boots have a drawcord, elastic cuff, or hook-and-loop strap at the top, use it. Snug it so the boot cannot pull down over the ankle bone when you tug the toe, but not so tight that it leaves a mark.

If your boots have an open top, you can add a closure. A wide elastic hair band or a soft ponytail elastic around the cuff over the pant leg works better than it has any right to. Cut the toe off an old sock and pull the tube over the boot top as a gaiter. Neither is pretty. Both keep the boot on.

If you are buying new boots, buy ones with a cuff that closes. It solves this problem before it starts, which is why soft boots for the under-two age group are built that way.

For amphibious babies.

Waterproof crawling booties, $39.99. Two sizes, five colorways. Preorders open.

Preorder

2. Pull the pants over, then cinch

Where the pant leg goes changes everything.

Pants tucked into the boot leave a gap for rain and bark chips, and the pant leg pushes up inside the boot, lifting the heel. Pants over the boot without a closure flap around and the boot still slides.

The combination that works: pant leg over the boot, then cinch the boot cuff over the pant leg. The pant fabric gives the cuff something to grip, and the seal keeps water out. Rain pants and one-piece rain suits are designed for exactly this. Footed pajamas under a boot work the same way.

3. Fix the size

A boot that is too big comes off. Everyone knows this. A boot that is too small also comes off, and that one surprises people.

Too big: the heel lifts with every step and the toe drags. Check by lifting your child under the arms. If the boot stays on the floor, it is too big or the cuff is not closed.

Too small: the boot is tight across the instep, so the foot does not seat down into it, and the first high step pops the heel out. Check by feeling for the toes through the end of the boot. Less than a quarter inch of room means too small.

Measure the foot with a tracing and check the brand's chart rather than going by shoe size. Our sizing guide walks through it in two minutes.

For age-sized soft boots, check the brand's chart for the foot length each size is cut for; ours is on how they work. If a child is between sizes, go up and tighten the cuff.

4. Change the socks

Socks are the interface between foot and boot, and they are often the problem.

  • Slick socks: thin nylon or polyester dress socks slide against the boot lining. Switch to cotton-wool blend or wool.
  • Too-thin socks: a thin sock in a boot with growth room leaves the foot swimming. A thicker sock takes up the space and gives the boot something to hold.
  • Too-thick socks: the opposite problem in a snug boot. The foot cannot seat and the heel pops.
  • Socks that slide down inside the boot. A sock bunched under the arch lifts the heel. Taller socks pulled up over the calf stay put.

Grippy-bottom socks, the kind with rubber dots for hardwood floors, work well inside boots too. The dots grab the lining.

5. Lighten the boot

Weight is the quiet reason boots fall off young toddlers. A pair of classic rubber boots in a toddler size can weigh close to a pound and a half. A 14 month old's leg is not built to swing that.

You cannot make a heavy boot light. You can decide whether the weight is worth it. For a child under two who is mostly carried, pushed, or taking first steps, a soft boot in the 3 to 6 ounce range stays on because there is nothing pulling it off. The weight comparison in rubber vs. neoprene vs. soft-shell has typical numbers for each type.

6. Tether them

For the stroller and carrier specifically, a tether means a kicked-off boot does not become a lost boot.

Mitten clips or small toy leashes clip from a pull loop on the boot to the pant leg or the stroller strap. A loop of elastic cord sewn or tied through the boot's pull tab and around the ankle inside the pant leg does the same thing. It does not keep the boot on. It keeps the boot in your possession, which on a wet day is the next best thing.

This is a backup, not a fix. If you are tethering every outing, go back to fixes one through five.

7. Change the routine

Some of this is behavior, not gear.

Toddlers kick boots off because it is interesting, because the boots are uncomfortable, or because they have learned that a boot coming off ends the walk and gets attention. You cannot argue with an 18 month old, but you can change the setup.

  • Put boots on last, right before going out, so there is no indoor kicking time.
  • Put them on in the stroller or carrier rather than before loading. Fewer steps between boot and door.
  • Check for discomfort. A sock seam across the toes, a tag at the heel, or a boot that is cold inside all produce the same kick-it-off response.
  • Make the walk the reward. If a kicked-off boot means a stop and a fuss, kicking gets reinforced. If it means a quick re-boot and keep moving, it fades.
  • For a child old enough, give them a job: pulling the cuff snug, or checking that both boots are on at the first corner.

When the boot is the problem

If you have closed the cuff, fixed the size, changed the socks, and the boot still comes off daily, the boot type does not match the age. This is extremely common with classic rubber boots on children under two. They are built on a shoe last with a defined heel pocket, they are heavy, and they have nothing above the ankle. No fix overcomes all three.

For that age, the boot that stays on has a soft upper that goes on over clothing, a tall cuff with a cinch, light weight, and age-based sizing cut for a short, wide foot and a thick ankle. That is the type to look for. Our own product is narrower than that: Newt Boots are waterproof crawling booties for the crawling stage, roughly 6 to 18 months, worn over a rain suit, in two sizes, 6 to 12 months and 12 to 18 months, at $39.99. They are for babies on hands and knees, not for walking toddlers. If a pair does not work out, returns are simple: 60 days, and free size swaps. Details are in the shop.

For an older child, two and a half and up with a real heel, rubber and neoprene boots stay on fine once the size is right, and the fixes above are all you need.

A quick checklist for the door

  1. Right socks: wool or cotton blend, pulled up, no bunching.
  2. Boot seated: push the heel down, feel for toe room.
  3. Pants over the boot.
  4. Cuff cinched over the pants.
  5. Lift test: pick the child up under the arms. Boots stay on? Go.

Thirty seconds, and it saves a trip back for a boot in a puddle. More ways to make wet days easier are in how to dress a baby for rain.

FAQ

Why do my toddler's boots keep falling off?
Children under about two have a soft, shallow heel that cannot grip a boot's heel pocket, and they kick and high-step constantly. An open-top boot has nothing else to hold it. A cuff that closes above the ankle fixes most cases.
How do I keep rain boots on a baby in a carrier?
Use a boot with a cuff that cinches over the pant leg or bunting, keep the boot light, and tether the pull loop to the pants as a backup. Open-top rubber boots will not stay on a kicking carrier foot.
Should toddler boots be tight to stay on?
Snug at the cuff, not tight at the foot. A boot that is tight across the instep pops off the heel. Allow about a quarter to half an inch of toe room and close the cuff firmly over the pants.
Do thicker socks help boots stay on?
Often, yes, if the boot has growth room. A thicker wool or cotton-blend sock fills the space and grips the lining. In a snug boot, a thicker sock makes it worse.
What kind of boot stays on a one year old?
A soft boot with a tall cinching cuff, a flexible sole, light weight, and age-based sizing. Classic rubber boots rarely stay on at this age no matter how you adjust them.
The Newt Boots field desk
Parents and outdoor-business owners in Hood River, Oregon. We make waterproof crawling booties and spend a lot of time outside in the rain. About us.

Keep reading.

All field notes