Preorders are open. $39.99 a pair, two sizes, five colorways. Reserve a pair.
Home›Field notes›Buying guides›Rain Boots vs. Snow Boots for Toddlers: Which Do You Need?
Field note Nº 23 · Buying guides · · 7 min

Rain Boots vs. Snow Boots for Toddlers: Which Do You Need?

Rain boots vs snow boots for toddlers: how they differ in warmth, waterproofing, weight, and traction, when one pair can do both jobs, and when you need two.

If your winters are mostly rain with occasional slush, a lined rain boot does the whole job. If your winters mean real snow on the ground for weeks and temperatures in the teens and twenties, a toddler needs a snow boot, and the rain boot stays in the closet until March. The two are built for different problems: rain boots are about keeping water out, snow boots are about keeping heat in. Most families in wet, mild climates can get by with one pair; families in snow country need both or one well-chosen crossover.

Here is how they differ, how to decide for your climate, and how to handle the stage when your toddler is too small for either to fit well.

The core difference

Rain boots are a waterproof shell with little or no insulation. They keep liquid water out of the boot. Warmth comes from the sock and, in lined versions, a fleece layer.

Snow boots are an insulated boot with a waterproof or water-resistant lower section. They keep heat in and keep snow out. The insulation is thick, often synthetic fill rated for temperatures well below freezing, and the sole is thick and lugged for traction on packed snow and ice.

A rain boot in deep snow lets snow in over the top and gets cold fast because there is nothing holding heat. A snow boot in standing water often leaks at the upper, because the upper is usually a water-resistant fabric rather than a sealed shell, and once the insulation is wet it stays wet.

Side by side

Rain boot Lined rain boot Snow boot
Keeps water out Yes, fully Yes, fully Lower boot yes, upper often only water-resistant
Warmth Low, from sock Medium, fleece liner High, insulated fill
Temperature range Above about 40 F About 25 to 50 F Below freezing to about 40 F
Weight (toddler) Light to medium Medium Heavy
Sole Thin to medium, flexible to stiff Same Thick, lugged, stiff
Height Mid-calf Mid-calf Mid-calf to high, often with a snow collar
Dries after soaking Fast Liner removable on good ones Slowly
Stays on a toddler Depends on cuff Depends on cuff Usually has a strap or lace

For amphibious babies.

Waterproof crawling booties, $39.99. Two sizes, five colorways. Preorders open.

Preorder

When a rain boot is enough

A rain boot, especially a lined one, covers these winters:

  • Pacific Northwest lowlands, coastal California, the Southeast, the UK, most of the mid-Atlantic. Rain, drizzle, 35 to 55 degrees, snow that melts the same day.
  • Any climate where the ground is wet more often than it is frozen.
  • Toddlers who are mostly carried or in a stroller rather than playing in snow.

In these conditions, warmth is a sock-and-liner problem. A rain boot with a wool sock is comfortable into the 40s. Add a fleece liner and it handles the 30s for a walk or a park visit. The boot stays light and flexible, which matters for a child under two who is still learning to walk and does not need to lug a snow boot around a wet playground.

A removable liner is the best version of this. Liner in from November to February, liner out for the shoulder seasons. One boot, five months of use. Newt Boots are a different thing again: waterproof crawling booties for the crawling stage, 6 to 18 months, worn over a rain suit, in two sizes, 6 to 12 and 12 to 18 months. They are for a crawler on wet ground, not a snow boot and not a boot for a walking toddler, and we would not sell them to you as either. For a child who plays in snow regularly, read on.

When you need a snow boot

A snow boot earns its place when:

  • Snow stays on the ground for days or weeks
  • Temperatures sit below freezing for most of the day
  • Your toddler plays in the snow rather than passing through it: sledding, digging, sitting in it
  • You are going to a snow destination for more than a quick visit

In those conditions a rain boot fails in two ways. Snow comes in over the cuff and melts inside, and the thin shell transfers cold straight through to the foot. A fleece liner helps for a while but is not rated for an afternoon in the teens.

Snow boots solve this with insulation, a higher cuff or a snow collar that cinches over snow pants, and a thick sole that keeps the foot off the frozen ground. The tradeoffs are weight, stiffness, and slow drying.

The toddler-specific problems

Both boot types have an age problem under about two.

Snow boots are heavy. A toddler-size snow boot can weigh 10 to 14 ounces each. On a 15 month old that is a lot of boot. Many new walkers in snow boots walk like astronauts and give up after a few minutes. If your toddler is mostly in a sled or carrier in the snow, warmth matters and weight does not. If they are supposed to walk, the lightest snow boot you can find is the one to buy.

Rain boots in the classic rubber style fall off. Under two, a child has little heel to hold a boot, so an open-top rubber boot slides off in the stroller and the snow. A soft rain boot with a cinching cuff solves this, which is why that type suits the age group.

Snow boots usually have a strap or lace, which helps them stay on, and a snow collar to cinch. They still fit on a shoe last with a heel pocket, so the fit on a small, soft foot is approximate. More on the stay-on problem in how to keep boots on a toddler.

Can one pair do both?

Sometimes. The crossover options:

Lined rain boot with a removable liner. Best for wet-mild climates with occasional cold snaps. Not for real snow.

Neoprene boot. Fully waterproof, insulating on its own, and often rated into the 20s. The best single boot for a climate that swings between rain and light snow. Heavy-ish, slow to dry inside, and fits best from about 18 months because of the heel pocket. See rubber vs. neoprene vs. soft-shell for how neoprene compares.

Waterproof snow boot with a sealed lower shell. Some snow boots have a molded rubber lower that is truly waterproof to a few inches, with insulation above. In slush and shallow puddles they work as rain boots. They are hot and heavy in a 50 degree drizzle.

If you have to pick one and you live where winter is mostly wet, buy the lined rain boot. If you live where winter is mostly white, buy the snow boot and accept that spring puddles will soak the upper a few times.

What to wear with each

Rain boot: wool or wool-blend socks, never cotton. Rain pants or a rain suit with the cuff over the boot and the boot cuff cinched over that.

Snow boot: a wool sock, not two socks, which compresses the insulation and restricts circulation. Snow pants over the boot with the inner gaiter inside the boot and the outer cuff over it. A dry change of socks in the bag.

For both, a boot that is too tight is a cold boot. Compressed insulation and restricted blood flow do more to chill feet than a thin shell does. Size with room for the sock. The sizing guide covers how.

How cold is too cold

Boots are only part of the picture. A toddler's time outside in the cold depends on wind, wet, activity, and how well the rest of them is dressed. Babies and toddlers lose heat faster than adults and cannot always tell you they are cold. Check the back of the neck and the belly for warmth, watch for pale or red skin on exposed areas, and plan warm-up breaks on days near freezing. How cold is too cold for a baby outside goes through the signs and the limits in more detail.

Our recommendation by climate

Wet and mild, snow rare: one lined rain boot with a removable liner, or an unlined rain boot plus wool socks. Buy the lightest, softest boot that fits and stays on.

Wet with a few real snow days: lined rain boot for daily use. For the snow days, a sled, warm socks, and short outings. A second pair of snow boots is optional for a child under two who will not be walking in the snow much.

Cold and snowy, snow on the ground for weeks: snow boots for winter, the lightest you can find for a child under two. A rain boot for fall and spring, since the snow boot will be sweaty and leaky in the puddle months.

Mountain or variable: neoprene as a single boot from 18 months, or lined rain boot plus snow boot if you can swing two pairs.

FAQ

Can toddlers wear rain boots in the snow?
For a quick walk through light snow or slush, yes, with wool socks and ideally a fleece liner. For playing in snow or temperatures well below freezing, no. Snow comes in over the top and a thin shell does not hold heat.
Can toddlers wear snow boots in the rain?
For a short time, yes. Most snow boots have a water-resistant fabric upper that will soak through in steady rain or standing water, and wet insulation stays wet. In a mild rainy climate they are also too hot.
Do toddlers need snow boots?
Only if they will be in real snow or sub-freezing temperatures regularly. In wet, mild climates a lined rain boot with wool socks is enough. Toddlers who are carried or sledded rather than walking in snow need warmth more than they need a heavy boot.
What is the difference between rain boots and snow boots?
Rain boots are a waterproof shell with little insulation; they keep water out. Snow boots are an insulated boot with a thick sole and a high cuff; they keep heat in and snow out, and the upper is often only water-resistant.
Are lined rain boots warm enough for winter?
In climates where winter means rain and temperatures mostly above freezing, yes, with wool socks. For extended time below freezing or in snow, they are not a substitute for an insulated snow boot.
The Newt Boots field desk
Parents and outdoor-business owners in Hood River, Oregon. We make waterproof crawling booties and spend a lot of time outside in the rain. About us.

Keep reading.

All field notes